← 論文一覧に戻る

印象管理の手法としてのグラフ:危機前・危機中・危機後のJSEトップ40統合報告書からの証拠

Graphs as an Impression Management Tactic: Evidence from JSE Top 40 Integrated Reports Before, During and After a Crisis (原題)

Ramatsobane Mahlako Maleka, Vanessa M. Gregory, Masibulele Phesa

International Journal of Financial Studies📚 査読済 / ジャーナル2026-10-19#開示インフラ
DOI: 10.3390/ijfs14100283
原典: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijfs14100283

🤖 gxceed AI 要約

日本語

南アフリカJSE上場トップ40社の統合報告書200冊・8,427グラフを分析し、COVID-19危機の前・中・後でグラフの頻度・選択性・測定歪みがどう変化したかを検証。危機中はグラフ密度が上昇し危機後に戻る一方、円グラフや非財務グラフの比率は危機後も高いままだった。歪み指標(GDIとRGD)で結論が大きく変わり、測定歪みよりも選択性の方が強い印象管理手法であることを示す。

English

Analyzes 8,427 graphs across 200 JSE Top 40 integrated reports to test whether graph frequency, selectivity, and measurement distortion shift before, during, and after COVID-19. Graph density rose during the crisis and normalized after, while pie charts and non-financial graphs stayed elevated. Distortion prevalence varies sharply by index (GDI 54.9% vs RGD 19.1%), and selectivity emerges as a stronger impression-management tactic than distortion.

Unofficial AI-generated summary based on the public title and abstract. Not an official translation.

📝 gxceed 編集解説 — Why this matters

日本のGX文脈において

日本では統合報告書や有報の非財務情報拡充が進み、SSBJ開示と並んで「監査対象外の記述・図表」の信頼性が論点化している。グラフ操作の実証手法は日本企業の統合報告書レビューや投資家向け開示品質評価に応用可能。

In the global GX context

As ISSB/SSBJ and CSRD push more non-financial narrative into reports, this study's evidence that unaudited graphs are selectively used—and that distortion metrics themselves shape conclusions—matters for disclosure-quality assessment and greenwashing scrutiny globally.

👥 読者別の含意

🔬研究者:非財務開示における印象管理の測定指標(GDI/RGD)の感度差を踏まえ、単一指標依存の限界を示す実証として参照できる。

🏢実務担当者:統合報告書のグラフ作成・選択が投資家に与える印象を自覚し、開示レビュー体制の整備に活用できる。

🏛政策担当者:非財務情報の監査・保証範囲を設計する際、図表やグラフの選択性が規制対象となり得る点を示唆する。

📄 Abstract(原文)

Integrated reports rely heavily on graphs, yet the content outside the annual financial statements is not audited, which leaves room for graphs to be used to manage users’ impressions. Crisis conditions are expected to increase the pressure on management to protect legitimacy, but little is known about how graphical impression management changes before, during and after a crisis, and prior studies usually rely on a single distortion index. This study examines whether the top 40 JSE-listed companies use graphs as an impression management tactic, and whether graph frequency, selectivity, and measurement distortion differed across the periods before (2018 to 2019), during (2020 to 2021), and after (2022 to 2025) the COVID-19 crisis. A quantitative content analysis was conducted on 8427 graphs across 34,720 report pages from 200 integrated reports. Distortion was measured by the Graph Discrepancy Index (GDI) and the Relative Graph Discrepancy Index (RGD), and differences between periods were evaluated using chi-square tests. Graph density rose during the crisis and returned to its pre-crisis levels afterwards, while the shares of pie charts and non-financial graphs increased during the crisis and remained higher afterwards. Favourable key financial variable (KFV) trends outnumbered unfavourable ones in every period, and their share rose from 62.5% before the crisis to 87.1% after it, which may partly reflect the recovery in company results. The GDI classified 54.9% of the measurable KFV graphs as materially distorted, compared with 19.1% under the RGD, but across indices, material distortion did not favour management more often than it worked against it. Selectivity appears to be a stronger impression management tactic than measurement distortion. This study extends the graph disclosure literature with insights from the crisis setting in South Africa, showing that the choice of distortion index can materially change conclusions about how common distortion is.

🔗 Provenance — このレコードを発見したソース

🔔 こうした論文の新着を逃したくない方は キーワードアラート に登録(無料・3キーワードまで)。

gxceed は公開メタデータに基づく研究支援データセットです。要約・翻訳・解説は AI 支援で生成されています。 最終的な解釈・検証は利用者が原典資料に基づいて行うことを前提とします。