ESG格付の実相:企業の視点と制度化のダイナミクス
Unveiling ESG ratings: corporate perspectives and institutionalisation dynamics (原題)
Zeynep Hazal Kopal, Leonardo Boni, Mario Calderini
🤖 gxceed AI 要約
日本語
欧州上場企業のサステナビリティ責任者45名へのインタビューを基に、ESG格付が企業内でいかに制度化されるかを制度理論の観点から分析。格付への対応は実質的統合から象徴的正当化まで連続的に分布し、制度圧力に規定されることを示す。格付の限界が放置されれば脱制度化のリスクがあると警鐘を鳴らす。
English
Drawing on 45 interviews with sustainability executives at listed European firms, this study uses institutional theory to examine how ESG ratings become institutionalised within organisations. It develops a framework distinguishing substantive integration of sustainability into operations from symbolic use of ratings for legitimacy, showing adoption unfolds along a continuum shaped by institutional pressures. The authors warn of deinstitutionalisation if rating limitations remain unaddressed.
Unofficial AI-generated summary based on the public title and abstract. Not an official translation.
📝 gxceed 編集解説 — Why this matters
日本のGX文脈において
SSBJ基準・有報開示が進む日本でも、ESG評価機関との対話や格付対応は実務課題。象徴的対応と実質的統合を見分ける診断的視点は、日本企業の統合報告・投資家対応の質的向上に示唆を与える。
In the global GX context
As ISSB/CSRD and SEC climate disclosure raise scrutiny of ESG data, this paper speaks directly to global debates on rating credibility, greenwashing and the symbolic-versus-substantive divide in corporate disclosure. It adds a rated-firm perspective to disclosure-infrastructure scholarship.
👥 読者別の含意
🔬研究者:ESG格付の制度化・脱制度化を制度理論で捉える枠組みを、企業対応研究に応用できる。
🏢実務担当者:自社の格付対応が象徴的か実質的かを診断し、開示の質を高める手がかりになる。
🏛政策担当者:ESG格付の限界を放置すれば信頼が損なわれる点を、評価機関規制の議論に反映すべき。
📄 Abstract(原文)
Purpose Environmental, social and governance (ESG) ratings have become a central mechanism for assessing, benchmarking and signalling corporate sustainability performance to financial investors. Yet, their widespread use persists despite ongoing criticism of their capacity to accurately reflect firms’ social and environmental contributions. This paper aims to examine this paradox from the perspective of rated companies, exploring why firms continue to engage with ESG ratings despite criticism of their effectiveness, even as investors remain their primary users. Drawing on institutional theory, the authors adopt this underexplored perspective and investigate how ESG ratings become institutionalised within organisations. Design/methodology/approach Based on abductive thematic analysis of 45 semi-structured interviews with sustainability executives from listed European firms, the authors develop a framework distinguishing between substantive and symbolic forms of ESG rating institutionalisation. Findings ESG rating adoption is shaped by institutional pressures and unfolds along a continuum. At one end, firms substantively integrate sustainability considerations into core operations; at the other, ESG ratings are used symbolically to secure external recognition and legitimacy. This study also highlights the risk of deinstitutionalisation if the limitations of ESG ratings remain unaddressed. Practical implications This study offers managers, investors and policymakers insights into navigating ESG pressures and strengthening the credibility of ESG frameworks while providing a diagnostic lens to distinguish symbolic compliance from substantive integration. Social implications While the potential deinstitutionalisation of ESG ratings could erode credibility, accountability and investor trust, substantive adoption could benefit transparency, stakeholder oversight and the diffusion of sustainability norms. Addressing their limitations is therefore crucial for maintaining credibility in the financial sector and directing capital towards companies with meaningful sustainability practices. Originality/value This study extends research on corporate responses to ESG ratings by drawing on institutional theory and developing a conceptual framework of symbolic and substantive institutionalisation from the perspective of rated companies. Specifically, it shifts the explanatory focus beyond firms’ strategic orientations by showing that corporate responses are also shaped by the institutional characteristics and structural limitations of ESG rating systems, thereby advancing the concept of ESG ratings’ deinstitutionalisation.
🔗 Provenance — このレコードを発見したソース
- openalex https://doi.org/10.1108/sampj-03-2025-0389first seen 2026-11-18 06:14:40
🔔 こうした論文の新着を逃したくない方は キーワードアラート に登録(無料・3キーワードまで)。
gxceed は公開メタデータに基づく研究支援データセットです。要約・翻訳・解説は AI 支援で生成されています。 最終的な解釈・検証は利用者が原典資料に基づいて行うことを前提とします。