持続可能金融における格付不一致の持続性・測定頑健性・情報信頼性:中国上場企業のESG透明性とエビデンス基盤のサステナビリティ・ガバナンスへの示唆
Persistent Rating Disagreement, Measurement Robustness, and Information Reliability in Sustainable Finance: Implications for ESG Transparency and Evidence-Based Sustainability Governance in Chinese Listed Companies (原題)
Stephen Kamran, Farah Saman
🤖 gxceed AI 要約
日本語
中国上場377社・1,323社年次の2019〜2024年パネルでMSCIとFTSE RussellのESG評価不一致を検証。平均絶対パーセンタイル不一致は0.2493、翌年Spearman相関は約0.493で中程度の持続性を示す。標準化手法の違いが企業規模など財務関連の推論結論を変え、測定感応性の重要性を浮き彫りにする。ESG不一致を情報ガバナンス課題として位置づけ、格付比較と透明な調和・感応度評価を提言する。
English
Using a 2019–2024 panel of 1,323 firm-years across 377 Chinese listed firms, the study compares MSCI- and FTSE Russell-attributed ESG assessments. Mean absolute percentile-rank disagreement is 0.2493, and consecutive-year Spearman correlation of ~0.493 indicates moderate persistence. Alternative harmonisation methods change inferences about financial associations such as firm size, underscoring measurement sensitivity. The authors frame ESG disagreement as an information-governance challenge and call for transparent provider comparison and sensitivity assessment.
Unofficial AI-generated summary based on the public title and abstract. Not an official translation.
📝 gxceed 編集解説 — Why this matters
日本のGX文脈において
SSBJ・有報サステナビリティ開示の整備が進む日本でも、格付プロバイダー間の不一致と測定手法の感応性は投資家対応・開示ガバナンスの実務課題であり、評価調和の設計に示唆を与える。
In the global GX context
Amid ISSB/CSRD-driven consolidation of sustainability disclosure, this paper quantifies how provider disagreement persists over time and how harmonisation choices alter conclusions — directly relevant to evidence-based ESG governance and rating-transparency debates globally.
👥 読者別の含意
🔬研究者:ESG格付不一致の測定手法依存性と時系列持続性を、再現可能な枠組みで扱う実証例として参照できる。
🏢実務担当者:複数格付の比較・調和と感応度評価を開示情報管理プロセスに組み込む根拠になる。
🏛政策担当者:格付プロバイダー比較と透明な調和手法の制度化を検討する際の実証的裏付けとなる。
📄 Abstract(原文)
This study investigates cross-provider environmental, social, and governance (ESG) rating disagreement, temporal persistence, and measurement robustness, with particular emphasis on improving the reliability of sustainability information for ESG management and financial decision-making. Using an unbalanced panel of 1,323 firm-year observations representing 377 Chinese listed companies during 2019–2024, the study compares MSCI- and FTSE Russell-attributed assessments. Disagreement is operationalised through percentile-rank, standardised-score, and min-max transformations. The analysis integrates descriptive statistics, consecutive-year Spearman correlation, exploratory panel regressions, firm-clustered inference, multiple-testing adjustments, and reproducible computational verification. The mean absolute percentile-rank disagreement is 0.2493, indicating appreciable differences in relative corporate assessments. A consecutive-year Spearman correlation of approximately 0.493 demonstrates moderate temporal persistence. Alternative harmonisation procedures produce different inferential conclusions concerning exploratory financial associations, particularly firm size, highlighting the importance of measurement-sensitive interpretation. The study integrates disagreement magnitude, temporal persistence, and measurement robustness within a reproducible framework, extending ESG divergence research beyond isolated provider comparisons. Drawing on Institutional Theory and information asymmetry, it positions ESG disagreement as an information-governance challenge rather than direct evidence of inaccurate sustainability performance. The findings support systematic provider comparison, transparent rating harmonisation, and sensitivity assessment in ESG information management. Such practices offer a basis for improving evidence scrutiny and decision transparency, subject to limitations concerning secondary-data provenance, panel composition, and observational inference.
🔗 Provenance — このレコードを発見したソース
- openalex https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/sd84g_v1first seen 2026-11-18 06:19:25 · last seen 2026-11-18 06:19:26
🔔 こうした論文の新着を逃したくない方は キーワードアラート に登録(無料・3キーワードまで)。
gxceed は公開メタデータに基づく研究支援データセットです。要約・翻訳・解説は AI 支援で生成されています。 最終的な解釈・検証は利用者が原典資料に基づいて行うことを前提とします。